Our fascination with fluorescents and the end of the affair?
Steve Edwards, Technical Director at our LED specialist client Light Planet, was somewhat taken aback this week by the widespread media attention over news that US researchers have developed a new type of lighting that could replace fluorescent bulbs. The concept of light from polymers is certainly intriguing, but we already have viable alternatives for fluorescents that do all of the above. So why are we under the impression that we don’t?
Our fascination with fluorescents and the end of the affair?
“To understand the context we need to look back. The UK has long had a fascination with the T8 fluorescent tube. Wherever you look; whether waiting for a train, riding a bus, working in an office, shopping in a department store, or parking in a car park, the T8 fluorescent is ever present.
Why is the T8 so popular? In a nutshell, a T8 tube emits a lot of light for relatively little power consumption. It also emits all of the way around its surface allowing lighting designers to use reflectors to bounce light around a room.
More recently, the T8 fluorescent has been superseded by the thinner T5. Despite a belief that the T5 is more efficient than the T8, the typical lumen efficacy of a T8 (86-94%) and T5 are, essentially, the same. Other forms of fluorescent technology also exist, including compact fluorescent, 2D, and PL lamps (the curly, low energy lamps sold in their thousands).
Despite this popularity, there are several facts about fluorescent lights that you won’t read on the box. A fluorescent lamp is filled with a gas containing low-pressure mercury vapour. The mercury vapour is excited by electricity to produce UV light. The inner surface of the bulb is coated with a fluorescent (and slightly phosphorescent) coating made of varying blends of metallic and rare-earth phosphor salts. The UV light causes the phosphor coating to ‘fluoresce’, which re-radiates the energy as visible light.
If a fluorescent light is broken, the mercury inside can be released into the air or ground and it is advisable to vacate the room for several minutes if this happens. The reason that we have to dispose of fluorescents in managed recycle centres is that they have to be carefully dismantled in a controlled environment to stop pollution of the ground and atmosphere. It is not just the construction and operation of the fluorescent that causes problems, in practice the performance of a fluorescent is often over played.
Typically a 58W T8 fluorescent claims to emit up to 5,600 lumen with an average lifespan of 20,000 hours, or 2.3 years at continuous run. A 54W T5 fluorescent is rated at up to at 5,000 lumen with the same lifespan. However, how these figures are arrived at needs some consideration. This light output is measured at a room temperature of 35° C. With winter starting to bite, even those of us in over-heated offices know that the room temperature is no-where near this high in normal buildings. At a more comfortable 25°C, the light output is reduced to approximately 89% for the same power consumption. In addition, the lifetime figure is achieved when the light is run in a 3-hour switching cycle (3 hours on, 15 minutes off). When the light is run in any other way (which it almost certainly will be) the lifetime is reduced.
These factors have long since led luminaire designers to look for viable alternatives. A LED (a light-emitting diode) is a semiconductor that converts electricity into light. Traditionally associated with the small red light on your TV monitor or remote, LED lighting technology has seen major development in recent years, fast-becoming a better alternative to traditional lighting technologies. LEDs emit a high light output for less power consumption (40-50% lower), have a higher luminous efficacy (up to 95%), a long-life (35,000 to 50,000 hours) and are safe with no strobing or flicker.
Architects, contractors and end-users are increasingly opting to install LED panel lights in place of the 4-tube fluorescent modular lights often seen in offices. So why not also retrofit LED tubes? The truth is that early adopters of LED tubes found them to be a disappointment. LED tubes are made, predominantly, from a plastic tube within which the LED chips and their driver electronics are mounted. When the LED heated up, the plastic tube could warp causing the light to fail. In addition, because LEDs emit light in one direction, when retrofitting into fluorescent fittings, the LED tubes could not always direct the light where it was needed.
But LED technology has moved on dramatically in recent years and design innovations have successfully eradicated these issues. The introduction of aluminium to the external structure of the LED tube now provides a structurally sound product, eliminating the warping common in early models. The continual development of the luminous efficacy of LEDs (how much light is emitted for power consumed) has seen figures in excess of 100 lumens per watt, which matches that of a T5 fluorescent. In my company, for example, several design innovations within our LED tube product range have dramatically increased our ability to compete in the traditional fluorescent market, including the advent of rotatable end caps that allow the installer to easily retrofit the tube into any fitting, and the introduction of LED tubes that emit light upwards as well as downwards emulating the all round light distribution of fluorescents. Read more about our innovations in tube lighting design here.
This kind of advanced technology is resulting in a steady increase in the adoption of LED tubes for property retrofit projects. Whilst the cost of LED is still relatively high compared to fluorescent, the high level of performance, length of reliable life span, safety and flexibility of these tubes positions them as an attractive and commercially viable alternative. The only real barrier to LED adoption is lack of understanding or experience with these products. New inventions in the field are welcome and will drive continued innovation, but perhaps we should pay more attention to the existing technology that’s ready and waiting.”
If your fluorescents have failed you can recycle them responsibly with Recolight. Try their free recycling locator here.